KenSmith said:
I like the bet of $500. You need every penny of it to guarantee second high. Small bets can't be seriously considered, because even a minimum bet surrender still leaves you exposed to trouble. So, bet the $500 and grab second high. If luckygem bets lower for some reason, you might even get first high.
I felt ok about the $500 bet at the time. But after the fact, I started to second-guess. If I bet high, I almost assuredly need to win or push, and even if I do, others could choose to double to pass me if I don't or can't double.
On the other hand, if I bet $10 with intent of surrendering, I win whenever Sunchi590 and tirle_bj both lose (I tie for 2nd if sunchi loses and tirle pushes) and even if one of them win, I stand a chance if luckygem bets big and wins.
I'm not sure which is the likelier scenario.
On to the play: tirle's excellent bet takes away the surrender play. Since tirle also has a basic strategy double, he's a big threat. Luckygem's hand of 19 is strong enough to be a problem for you as well. Hitting without doubling does little, because you'd have to make a hand of 20 or better to make it valuable. I'd double.
If you look at the results web page, you will see that I made a very bad decision. Though I would like to think it was partially due to the mechanics of playing online (a rare case where playing online makes the right decision harder). Bj_tirles bet appeared as a mishmosh of $100, $50 and $10 chips. Immediately after his bet appeared, my hand was dealt and my 20 second timer began. I would have had to calculate tirle's bet, figure out what hand everyone was dealt, and make my own decision in 20 seconds. I knew that sunchi couldn't get below me by surrendering, but I hadn't considered that if sunchi busted or surrendered, that BJ_tirle can lock me out by surrendering his 11. Honestly, I hadn't even considering tirle surrendering his 11, nor had I been able to calculate his bet to see who would win if he surrendered.
As the cards were, if I doubled-down I would have busted anyway, but I felt pretty stupid to lock myself out. But like you mentioned, bj_tirle made an excellent bet to put me in a world of hurt.