If I illustrate with numbers you or anyone else can always come back and say "yes, but" so I prefer to keep the discussion on this point based on principals. After all, it's the principal we're talking not numbers. Also, as you know, we're talking about a RULE OF THUMB to be applied when one is confused as to what bet to make and/or time is running out and you hear the dealer say "10 seconds".
By matching your opponent's bet you are taking a more conservative approach as opposed to betting 2x his/her bet. Depending on circumstances, you are pretty much guaranteeing that you will be the chip leader going into the final hand were you will be betting first. And as you know, having the chip lead gives you the advantage even if you bet first.
Depending on the amount of BR2's bet, if you bet 2x as a RULE OF THUMB you could very easily be over betting. A simple loss by BR1 can wipe out a substantial lead which would put you in a very bad situation on the last hand. And a swing can change your situation from very good to very bad the instant the dealer turns over that "I don't believe it" card.
To put it another way, BR1 worked the whole session to gain a substantial lead and it would be unwise to risk blowing that lead by making a huge bet without a well thought out reason for doing so. If I were BR2, keeping in mind that I'm in a very bad situation, I'd look on BR1's 2x RULE OF THUMB bet as my best opportunity to catch up.