Mulligan This
fgk42 said:
Hey Joe,
The Mulligan - let's call it a gimick shall we? - why is that BAD

for the game? Let's take the UBT knock out rounds while we're at it.
I'd really like to get your opinion and learn from it.
Fkg42 good question but you seem to have your tournaments mixed up
The Ultimate Blackjack Tour (UBT) does not have a knock out round .
What the UBT has is 4 separate and distinct elimination rounds on set hands 8-16-25-30 .When a player knows what is scheduled to happen at a specific time and what his betting position will be when that event happens he can skillfully plan his game plan.If his position changes prior to these hand based upon a player or players being eliminated before these hands then he or she has to make adjustment's in their game plan all part of a skillfully played tournament and one that will have you on the edge of your seats from hand 1 to hand 30 if it even gets that far.You see with the UBT format it could end at any time so buckle your seat belt there is a scheduled last hand but sometimes there is no need to play it.Hows that for a new and fresh change.
I have had the privilege of playing in season 1 of the UBT and also have seen a sneak preview of one of the shows.The post production work is outstanding .The format is the most demanding you will ever sink your teeth into it's not for the faint of heart and you best be paying attention to everyones chip totals right out of the gate.Trust me I have played in over 500 Blackjack Tournaments and this tournament is a perfect format for creating excitement and making for good TV.
I will buy you dinner in any restaurant of your choice if you don't think that a UBT style format is the best thing to happen to blackjack tournaments and to make it a worthwhile TV experience even for someone who has never watched a TV blackjack tournament before.
But because of the 4 ever pressing elimination hands this actually helps the newbies because the skilled players can not lurk around and out play you on the last 2 hands like they would under a normal tournaments structure .So in a way it levels the playing field out and it can and will be anyones game to win .
To address your other point as to my disdain for the "MULLIGAN"
Let me explain why
First off it was thrown in at the last minute without any prior warning from the Hilton and then they charged the players for it.This was in bad taste they advertise and promoted it as a FREE blackjack tournament to its customers who played at their tables and received a suited blackjack.
Once all the players arrived from all parts of the country they pulled the old bait & switch move.And to not make it look as bad as it was they decided to only charge 100 dollars for it.Was their thinking cheap enough that most players wont complain ?
Yet if all players bought it the Hilton just had a free tournament that the players paid for.There were over 1,000 players who qualified for this tournament. 100 X 1000 = 100,000.
If this was done in any normal business the State Attorney General would not look to kind on this move .
Here is an example an Auto Dealership advertises that if you come into their business and buy something you will be entered into a chance to win a brand new car.
The only catch is the car comes without an engine thats separate and you must purchase it to drive the car home. I hope you can see my point
The Hilton also stole the idea from GSN which has the Burger King have it your way chip .Now what's done to try and make TV shows entertaining is not always good for the real game of blackjack.A real tournament should be played by all players having to deal with the cards they are dealt and not a new hand if they don't like the hand that was dealt to them.
Name one sporting event that allows a team or players to change what just happened in a game because they didn't like what just happened.How many more bracelets would Phil Hellmut,Johnny Chan or Doyle Brunson have if they could change there cards after seeing the flop .Come on now :joker:
When is the last time anyone from the Hilton came up with something that was good for the players . They are in the process of trying to weed out all players that they suspect of being tournament players not just tournament players that can be considered Pros.
Watch out for the tall guy on swing sift with the bad posture he hates players that can play with an advantage.
I guess when he plays it OK though to play with an advantage . Almost like a cop that arrest you for smoking pot and then smokes it himself after work . :joker:
Joep