OK, a response on a multitude of topics
On the fairness of the internet qualifier:
As far as I'm concerned, the problem with the internet qualifier is not that he or she doesn't deserve it. The problem is that this event offers a prize to a freeroller, but them doesn't compensate the prize pool to accomodate it.
For example, if Barona comps 50 people to the main event, they would owe 50x $10,000 or $500,000 entry fees to the prize pool. But if the were all guaranteed a bye into a round 2 where 1 of 3 advanced out of round 1, then Barona should have to pay $30,000 per entry to be fair to the people who paid $10,000 per entry, then won a round to advance. This is similar to how internet tournaments have higher entry fees for a higher "step" tournament.
Now to allow UBT to "buy a player in" to the final table, they should owe the prize pool 16.7% of the total prize pool so as to be fair to the entrants who bought in to the tournament. Instead, the UBT pays nothing, which is essentially stealing from the player's prize pool to pay for UBT's promotion. That's what is not right about it.
On the Ken Smith vs. Fred bet:
I think this is a pretty fair bet, but Ken might have the upper hand. The winner of the freeroll will have to be pretty skilled to win the 7 or 8 tables required to win this freeroll. Compare this field to a field with about 50% comped players, and it's likely that the internet player will be more skilled than 1/2 the final table.
On the tax burden of a chop
This is not an issue. The IRS has specific forms that are used when a prize is split among multiple people. Everyone only becomes responsible for their share (the same way that a lotto prize gets split 50 ways when an office pool wins the lotto). If there's a final chop, everyone would fill out the form to document their share of the prize pool.
On the integrity of a chop only among certain players
I agree that this should be expressly forbidden. There is easily a lot of room here for collusion.
On the integrity of a full 100% chop
I agree with Kevin that this wouldn't really be right. I think that you need to leave something reasonable to play for. But this is really a case of the UBT making a guarantee of $1,000,000 for the winner (instead of just guaranteeing a $1,000,000 prize pool) that just hurts the event, from a player's perspective. If there were going to be 300 entrants at the ToC (like Barona had anticipated), this would have been a reasonable payout for first. But since we have no reason to expect anywhere near 300 people, this winner-take-all abomination is far more likely.
The chop I would propose if I was at the final table is either everyone recieving 5% or 10% of the prize pool and playing for the remaining share, or using the traditional schedule for UBT tournaments to pay out each place with 40% for 1st, 20% for 2nd down to 3% for 7th.
Besides correcting for the UBT bad planning, a chop from a tax perspective would result in less marginal tax rate to each player which would mean an overall reduction in the amount of the prize pool paid to Uncle Sam.